Welcome to the Italian Pie Shoppe, a hidden gem nestled within the vibrant bowling alley on 7107 N 42nd Ave, New Hope, MN. This delightful pizza restaurant invites you to indulge in a menu that reflects a blend of traditional Italian fare and a laid-back bowling alley atmosphere. With a welcoming phone line at +1 763-531-2692, it’s easy to connect with their friendly staff ahead of time.
The star of the show here is undoubtedly the pizza. Offering classics like the Build Your Own pizzas—available in both 14" thin crust and 12" deep or stuffed crust—partake in the personalization by selecting any three pizza ingredients. The prices, starting at US$16.99 for thin crust and US$17.99 for deep or stuffed, provide excellent value for a satisfying meal.
Highlights from customer experiences reflect that the deep dish pizza, while sometimes compared to Detroit-style, packs a filling punch with its generous cheese and savory, slightly sweet sauce. Notable mentions also go to their calzones and Italian fries, which have earned acclaim for their taste and quality. One customer shared, “We eat their deep dish pies at least once or twice a month,” demonstrating the community's affection for this establishment.
While the food shines bright, the ambiance leaves room for improvement. Reviews mention a rather chilly dining area that could be more inviting. Yet, the attached bowling alley breathes life into the experience, making it a suitable spot for gatherings with friends or family after a few games.
In conclusion, Italian Pie Shoppe offers a compelling pizza experience with flavors that resonate with traditional Italian roots. Though the atmosphere might not appeal to all, the food speaks volumes, promising a hearty meal that will leave you planning your next visit. If you're ever in the area, give this place a try; you might just find your new favorite spot for pizza in New Hope!
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
13 2nd Ave NW, St Joseph, MN 56374, United States
7600 2nd St N Ste B, Oakdale, MN 55128, United States
Carrer de Sant Pau, 9, 11, Ciutat Vella, 08001 Barcelona, Spain
41 Manning St, Kiama NSW 2533, Australia
1302 N Pace Blvd, Pensacola, FL 32505, United States
4974 Pacific Hwy, Halfway Creek NSW 2460, Australia
Am Löhbach 3, 57462 Olpe, Germany
Discover new menus and trending dishes on Menustic.
Menustic helps you discover menus from restaurants, cafés, and bars around the world. Explore destinations, compare dishes and prices, and decide where to eat or drink — Fantastic Menus, One Click Away.
© 2026 Menustic. Built to help people discover menus and decide what to eat and drink.
Nancy J
01/10/2025
The pizza is excellent - we love their thin crust pizza! We are always amazed though that there is NEVER anyone else in the dining room when we eat in. They do a lot of business that’s carried into the bowling alley but their dining room is empty. I can see why - it is a very uninviting room - for one thing it is always FREEZING in there - we kept our coats on the entire time we ate. It’s also very uncomfortable chairs. Make the dining room more inviting and I would guess you’d get a lot more business.
Tate Kindom
14/09/2025
Friendly staff serving with a smile. Great vibe with the bowling alley attached. Though the restaurant is very outdated, it's expected at an old bowling alley. I got a medium deep dish pizza. VERY filling, though it seemed less a deep dish and more Detroit style. The crust was the downfall as it was not as soft and airy as I'd like. Great cheese and I had no issues with toppings. The sauce is on the sweeter side, but savory as well. Although the pizza maybe wasn't award-winning (and a bit pricey), I was fat and happy at the end of the day. I wouldn't go out of my way for this pizza, but I would definitely be excited to order from here if I ever decide to knock down some pins.
Laura Klaas
14/09/2025
Cheese pizza, wonderful! Their pizzas have always been wonderful!! I wasn't from the area, and did not know it was in a bowling alley. It was packed! But very nice and fun people!! I wanted to stay and hang out! :)
Steve Garren
06/09/2025
We eat their deep dish pies at least once or twice a month. We feel it's the closest thing to the old My Pie Pizza that we can find, the ingredients are fresh and they're very generous with the cheese
Brent Nordquist
05/09/2025
Their calzones and Italian fries are fantastic. Friendly staff. Makes great take-out.
John Richard
02/08/2025
One of the BEST pizza places ever! When it comes to pizza I am kind of a conisoure. The sauce is great, the crust is awesome and they are very generous with cheese. For a special treat get the pizza fries! One of our favorite items is the chicken strips with a side of buffalo sauce and ranch dressing. There is also a bowling alley there. The lanes are awesome, well maintained. The resturaunt and bowling alley is always clean and well staffed. The staff is very friendly and helpful! One of the true Gems of New Hope!
Tony Stoutenburg
20/07/2025
The food is First Rate. If you like Chicago style pizza, pick it up here. Best I've had in the Twin Cities. But the atmosphere is not the draw. The staff was great, but the setting is ... well, the spare room at a bowling alley.